Welcome to MindCipher, a social repository of the world's greatest brain teasers, logic puzzles and mental challenges.

Tea and Wine

You take a spoon of wine from a barrel of wine and put it into your cup of tea. Then you return a spoon of the (non-uniform) mixture of tea and wine from your cup and put it in the barrel. Now you have some foreign substance (wine) in the cup and some foreign substance (tea) in the barrel. Which is larger: the quantity of wine in the cup or the quantity of tea in the barrel?

they are equal

This is pretty counter-intuitive. Two steps take place: 1. You move a spoonful of wine from the barrel to the cup. 2. You move a spoonful of mixture from the cup back to the barrel.

After step 1, there is 1 spoonful of wine in the cup. In step 2, you move x tea into the barrel and (1-x) wine into the barrel. Therefore, in the cup, you have 1-(1-x) = x wine remaining. x = the amount of tea in the barrel.

Comments


Stephen

One intuitive solution is:

The volume of liquid in both the cup and barrel remains the same as the initial state. If the net amounts of tea/wine transferred was not equal, the volumes would be different. Thus they must be equal.

  

Ravi

Hmm, that makes sense. I think the hardest part of this solution is intuitively understanding the duality between tea and wine proportions during the second transfer.


Tarun245

THEY ARE EQUAL CUZ YOU TOOK ONE SPOON OF EACH.


ylq

nike air max, 49ers jerseys, relojes, dansko shoes outlet, michael kors handbags, michael kors outlet online, polo ralph lauren, ralph lauren, rolex watches, michael kors, cheap ray ban, hogan mens shoes, nike air max, cheap michael kors, bengals jerseys, salvatore ferragamo, michael kors, ralph lauren outlet online, new balance, nike free run, fendi, vans schuhe, cheap basketball shoes, christian louboutin shoes, barbour mens jackets, cheap jerseys, bears jerseys, pandora charms, roshes, purses and handbags, iphone 4s cases, ipad mini cases, air max 2014, oakley sunglasses, portland trail blazers jersey, atlanta hawks jerseys, redskins jerseys, swarovski crystal, nfl jerseys, adidas sneakers, new orleans pelicans jersey, juicy couture, 76ers jerseys, oakley sunglasses, nba jerseys, tommy hilfiger, utah jazz jersey, air jordan retro, nike.com, houston rockets, warriors jerseys, adidas online shop, coach outlet online, ray ban outlet, ferragamo, hermes outlet, bulls jerseys, nike running shoes, burberry, tods womens shoes, calvin klein outlet, true religion outlet, converse chucks, tory burch handbags, true religion jeans men, oakley, nike air max, pandora bracelet, mcm handbags, versace outlet, nike blazers, givenchy shoes outlet, oakley sunglasses outlet, www.tommyhilfiger.nl, converse sneakers, michael kors handbags, washington wizards jersey, ralph lauren, tory burch, under armour outlet, orlando magic jersey, vans shoes, Herm├Ęs Pas Cher, coach black friday, the north face outlet, ray ban wayfarer, skechers womens shoes, mcm bags, long champ, tommy hilfiger online, oakley sunglasses, cowboys jerseys, prada outlet, true religion outlet, minnesota timberwolves jersey, nike free 5.0, hollister co, thomas sabo, adidas superstar, texans jerseys, new balance outlet, juicy couture outlet, birkenstock deutschland, michael kors purses, thomas sabo jewellery, rayban, bcbg max, salomon schuhe, toms outlet online, abercrombie, seahawks jerseys, timberland outlet, michael kors v?skor, nike factory, skechers canada, rayban, barbour jacket outlet, easton bats, jordan shoes, kate spade handbags, babyliss flat iron, coach factory outlet online, handbags outlet, the north face, fivefingers, mizuno running shoes, new balance, hollister co, oakley frogskins, ray ban wayfarer, oakley sunglasses cheap, hogan, michael kors outlet online, patriots jerseys, ray bans, air max, los angeles lakers, red bottom, nfl jerseys, vikings jerseys, montblanc, north face jackets, birkenstock taschen deutschland, lions jerseys, polo ralph lauren outlet online, thomas sabo uk, gafas oakley, coach factory outlet, nba jerseys, coach bags outlet, fred perry polos, longchamp handbags, jets jerseys, polo outlet online, cheap jerseys, coach outlet usa, burberry outlet store, kate spade bags, north face outlet, nike roshe run, packers jerseys, ralph lauren, jordan shoes, oakley sunglasses, swarovski online shop, burberry outlet online, marc by marc jacobs, philipp plein clothing, cheap oakley sunglasses, gucci store, fitflop shoes, pandora jewellery australia, adidas.se, bills jerseys, air max 90, prada tracksuits, burberry, barbour womens jackets, oakley sunglasses cheap, mcm backpack, browns jerseys, ed hardy clothing, cheap oakley sunglasses, michael kors bags, indiana pacers jersey, ray ban pas cher, coach bags outlet, woolrich womens jackets, ny jersey, louboutin shoes, cheap jerseys, red bottom shoes, polo ralph lauren, michael kors, guess bags, true religion jeans outlet, milwaukee bucks jersey, memphis grizzlies jersey, ray ban sunglasses, cheap oakley, longchamp handbags, eyeglasses stores, replica watches, michael kors, ferragamo, michael kors bags, mavericks jerseys, cavaliers jersey, tommy hilfiger outlet, pandora canada, nba jerseys, ralph lauren polo, eagles jerseys, replica watches, new balance shoes, hollister clothing, valentino outlet, chi flat iron, stone island, mbt womens shoes, hollister online, adidas yeezy shoes, jack wolfskin outlet online, jaguars jerseys, lacoste shirts, oakley sunglasses outlet, easton bats, c&c beanies, michael kors handbags, oakley sunglasses, vans outlet, nike air max, belstaff mens jackets, prada shoes, north face jackets, converse outlet, puma online shop, celine outlet, adidas shoes, nike air huarache, denver nuggets jerseys, louboutin, suns jersey, jimmy choo outlet, mizuno, lac jersey, mcm handbags, dolphins jerseys, lunette ray ban, panthers jerseys, nike shoes, ralph lauren online shop, michael kors outlet online sale, coach shop, hollisterco, gucci shoes store, veneta, air jordan shoes, hermes birkin bag, dsquared2 outlet, coach usa, barbour jackets, kate spade outlet, airmax, burberry outlet store, replica watches, sacramento kings, hilfiger online shop, under armour shoes, cheap oakley sunglasses, polo ralph, birkenstock, jordans for sale, mont blanc pens, converse shoes, rolex watches, burberry outlet online, soccer shoes, christian louboutin, detroit pistons, mcm handbags, giuseppe zanotti, retro jordans, michael kors handbags, bcbg max azria, prada handbags, bottega veneta, hilfiger outlet, ray-ban sunglasses, hermes belt, swarovski crystal, coach bags outlet, prada outlet, burberry online shop, kate spade, hogan sito ufficiale, purses and handbags, michael kors outlet online, toms outlet, nike air max thea, belstaff womens jackets, buccaneers jerseys, timberland outlet, michael jordan, ray ban outlet, ray ban occhiali, tommy hilfiger canada, fidget spinner, belstaff jackets outlet, northface, colts jerseys, burberry, cheap jerseys, ravens jerseys, nike air max, coach outlet store, adidas zx flux, guciheaven outlet, timberland boots, hornets jersey, swarovski australia, lacoste, air max thea, titans jerseys, puma shoes outlet, moncler women jackets, philipp plein, coach usa, moncler mens jackets, pandora charms, toms.com, nike huarache, saints jerseys, okc jerseys, supra footwear, true religion, longchamp taschen, nike.dk, giants jerseys, cheap nfl jerseys, nike fu?ballschuhe, rams jerseys, nike air max, cheap shoes, azcardinals jerseys, michael kors australia, hugo boss outlet online, nike store, ralph lauren outlet, longchamp, ferragamo shoes, steelers jerseys, north face, ray bans, chi hair, jimmy choo, nike store uk, nike free, burberry outlet store, coach outlet sale, prada, spurs jerseys, armani outlet online, ralph lauren outlet online, rolex, skechers outlet , reebok, roshe run, uggs outlet, michael kors uhren, nike running shoes, asics, polo ralph lauren, toms shoes outlet, g by guess, nike huarache, rayban, michael kors outlet, nike roshe run, toms shoes outlet, pandora charms, broncos jerseys, polo ralph lauren, polo outlet, ray ban uk, coach factory outlet online, ecco shoes outlet, coach factory online, nike running, uhren shop, ugg australia, longchamp outlet, toronto raptors jersey, replica rolex, red bottom, sunglasses for women, jordan retro, barbour jackets, polo ralph lauren outlet, pandora, oakley sunglasses, burberry outlet, adidas, nike.se, nfl jerseys, ray ban zonnebril, ralph lauren factory store, chrome hearts rings, nike schoenen, asics outlet, new balance, asics gel, ray ban sunglasses, reebok outlet, chargers jerseys, adidas superstar, the north face, levis jeans, nike roshe run, hollister, michael kors outlet, marc by marc jacobs, falcons jerseys, rolex replica, nike roshe run, cheap jerseys, swarovski, hoodies store, ferragamo shoes, north face canada, miami heat, nike tn, toms shoes outlet, air max, true religion jeans women, nike mercurial vapor, north face backpacks, raiders jerseys, fred perry outlet, air max 2014, designer handbags, swarovski jewelry, ralph lauren polo, chiefs jerseys, giuseppe zanotti sneakers, polo outlet store, michael kors outlet online sale, dsquared2, supra shoes, zapatillas nike, polo ralph lauren, timberland, burberry handbags outlet, nj jerseys, christian louboutin outlet, montre homme, nike shoes, celtics jersey, longchamp, burberry sale, oakley, nike soccer shoes, nike air force, cheap nike shoes, michael kors uk, soccer shoes outlet, versace, omega watches, michael kors, cheap michael kors, burberry sale, coach outlet online, cheap jack wolfskin

Check out other puzzles:
Random  

Like this? You might also like:
The Way Engineers Think
Attic Lamp Switch
The fake coin
Submitted by
Ravi
over 5 years ago
Likes
Difficulty 4.7 ?

Tags
Math logic


Back