Welcome to MindCipher, a social repository of the world's greatest brain teasers, logic puzzles and mental challenges.

Balloon in an Elevator

A person is holding on to a helium balloon in an elevator. The elevator cable snaps, and at the exact same moment, the person lets go of the helium balloon. In the perspective of the person in the elevator, what happens to the balloon the moment the cable snaps?

The balloon stays in place

Buoyancy is a direct consequence of gravity. In free fall, the effective gravity within the elevator is zero (assuming perfect free fall of the elevator, with no air drag) and thus the balloon stays where it is relative to the observer.

Comments


Timmmm

It will rise quicker than it would otherwise have, for fairly obvious reasons.

  

Ravi

When the lift is in free-fall, wouldn't it become weightless and therefore its contents would also become weightless? I would think that this would make the balloon drop towards the floor of the elevator. What's your reasoning Timmmm?


Valentin

The fundamental reason why the helium filled balloon floats is buoyancy. Buoyancy is a by-product of acceleration from the natural state of falling with gravity. In this case, he floor of the elevator is accelerating at exactly +g to stop you from descending. In free fall, the effective acceleration within the elevator is reduced to zero (or very close to it) and buoyancy no longer plays a factor. Thus the balloon stays where it is. This is the same fundamental reason why astronauts on the ISS float.

  

Ravi

In the confines of an elevator shaft where the area of the base of the elevator covers most of the cross-sectional area of the shaft, I would imagine the elevator would reach terminal velocity quite quickly and stop accelerating at G, at which point the balloon would go up. So I guess your answer is assuming an ideal case where the lift keeps accelerating at G?

  

Valentin

Yes that's a valid point. I was assuming air drag was not accounted for (i.e. moments after the cable snaps.)


David Sawicki

The balloon floats because it is lighter than air, so it would go to the ceiling very quickly, as the elevator, is falling.

                                 Dave  
Check out other puzzles:
Random  

Like this? You might also like:
Odd Pills
Sold!
The Number Problem
Submitted by
Aakash
almost 2 years ago
Likes
Difficulty 8.7 ?

Tags
physics relativity


Back